Differences Between Open-Back And Closed-Back Work From Home Headsets: Which Offers Better Soundstage?

Last Updated: May 2024

Table of Contents

If you work from home, you know how important it is to have the right equipment to ensure you can work efficiently and effectively. One of the most critical components of your home office setup is your headset. A good headset can make or break your work experience, especially if you need to communicate with colleagues or clients regularly.

When it comes to choosing a headset, you may have come across the terms ‘open-back’and ‘closed-back.’Understanding the differences between these two types of headsets can help you make a more informed decision about which one is best for your work from home setup.

Open-back and closed-back headsets have distinct features that affect their sound quality and overall performance. One significant difference between the two is their soundstage, or the ability to produce a 3D sound effect. Soundstage is essential for people who need to hear sounds with pinpoint accuracy, such as gamers or audio engineers.

In this article, we’ll explore the advantages and disadvantages of both open-back and closed-back headsets, with a specific focus on their soundstage capabilities. By the end of this article, you’ll have a better understanding of the differences between these two types of headsets and which one is best suited for your needs.

Key Takeaways

  • When choosing a headset for remote work, consider factors such as sound quality, comfort, durability, and connectivity.
  • Open-back headsets are beneficial for music production, mixing, and mastering, while closed-back headsets are ideal for noisy environments or concentration.
  • Personal preferences and needs should be taken into account when selecting between open-back and closed-back headsets.
  • Sound quality is influenced by factors such as frequency response, impedance, and sensitivity, as well as budget, environment, materials, detachable cables, weight and comfort, and driver type.

Overview of the Importance of Headsets in Remote Work

You can’t underestimate the importance of a good headset when working remotely – it’s key to ensuring clear communication and staying focused on your tasks. With the rise of remote work, headsets have become an essential tool for professionals who need to communicate with colleagues, clients, and customers from different locations.

A good headset can help you hear and be heard clearly, reduce background noise, and provide a comfortable listening experience for long hours of work. When choosing a headset for remote work, there are several factors to consider, such as sound quality, comfort, durability, and connectivity.

Open-back and closed-back headsets are two popular options, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. Open-back headsets have perforated ear cups that allow sound to pass through, creating a more natural and spacious soundstage. Closed-back headsets, on the other hand, have sealed ear cups that block out external noise and provide better isolation, making them ideal for noisy environments.

Ultimately, the choice between open-back and closed-back headsets depends on your personal preferences and the type of work you do.

Understanding Open-Back and Closed-Back Headsets

When it comes to headsets for remote work, it’s important to understand the difference between open-back and closed-back designs.

Open-back headsets have an open design that allows sound to escape and enter the ear cups, while closed-back headsets have a sealed design that isolates the sound.

The design and functionality of these headsets affect their advantages and disadvantages, making it important to choose the right type for your needs.

Design and Functionality

With an open-back headset, the design allows for more natural and spacious sound, providing a better listening experience overall. The open-back design allows air to flow through the ear cups, which helps to create a more natural soundstage. This design also allows for better ventilation, which can help to prevent overheating and discomfort during long use.

On the other hand, closed-back headsets are designed to block out external noise, creating a more isolated listening experience. This design can be useful for those who want to focus solely on their work or for those who work in noisy environments. Closed-back headsets also tend to have more bass, which can be useful for those who prefer a more bass-heavy sound. However, the closed-back design may not provide the same level of natural sound and spaciousness that an open-back headset can offer.

Advantages and Disadvantages

If you’re looking for a more isolated listening experience, a closed-back headset may be the way to go. Closed-back headphones have ear cups that are fully enclosed, which helps to prevent sound leakage. This means that you won’t disturb others around you, and you won’t be disturbed by external noise.

However, keep in mind that closed-back headphones may not offer the same natural sound and spaciousness as open-back headphones. The closed design can create a sense of ‘in your head’ sound, which can be fatiguing after prolonged use. Additionally, the enclosed design can cause a buildup of heat and moisture, which can make your ears feel uncomfortable.

Ultimately, the choice between open-back and closed-back headphones depends on your personal preferences and needs.

Soundstage and Its Importance in Headsets

Soundstage is a crucial aspect of headset performance that can be significantly impacted by the design of the headphones. Soundstage refers to the perceived spatial location and distance of sound sources in a recording. A good soundstage can provide a more immersive and realistic listening experience, especially for music and movies.

In headsets, soundstage is affected by several factors, including the size and shape of the ear cups, the distance between the drivers, and the acoustic properties of the materials used.

To understand the importance of soundstage in headsets, consider the following factors:

  • Sound localization: A good soundstage allows you to pinpoint the location of different instruments or sounds in a mix, giving you a better sense of the musical arrangement and the intended spatial effects. This can be especially useful for gaming or virtual reality applications where directional audio cues are essential.

  • Instrument separation: A good soundstage can also help you distinguish between different instruments and their individual timbres and harmonies, even in complex arrangements. This can make the music sound clearer and more detailed, and can enhance your appreciation of the performance and the production.

  • Depth and dimension: A good soundstage can create a sense of depth and dimension in the music, making it sound more three-dimensional and multi-layered. This can make the music more engaging and enjoyable, and can reveal subtle nuances and hidden details that may be missed with a flatter or narrower soundstage.

  • Context and realism: A good soundstage can also provide a sense of context and realism to the music, making it sound more like a live performance or a natural environment. This can enhance your emotional connection to the music, and can make you feel more present and involved in the experience.

Advantages of Open-Back Headsets

You’ll love the immersive and natural sound that open-back headsets provide, thanks to their unique design that allows sound to escape through the back of the ear cups. This type of headset creates a more spacious and open soundstage, which is ideal for music production, mixing, and mastering.

Open-back headsets are also great for gamers who want to feel like they’re in the middle of the action, as they provide a more realistic and natural sound.

In addition to their sound quality, open-back headsets are also more comfortable to wear for extended periods. They allow for better ventilation, which reduces heat and moisture buildup around your ears. This means you can wear them for hours without feeling uncomfortable or fatigued.

Furthermore, open-back headsets are generally lighter than closed-back ones, which makes them more comfortable to wear for long periods.

Overall, if you want a headset that provides a natural and immersive sound, and that is comfortable to wear for extended periods, then open-back headsets are the way to go.

Advantages of Closed-Back Headsets

For an enhanced listening experience, consider the advantages of closed-back headsets, which provide excellent noise isolation and a more focused sound. Closed-back headphones are designed with sealed ear cups that prevent sound from escaping, making them ideal for use in noisy environments or when you need to concentrate on your work.

The closed design also helps to prevent sound leakage, which means that your colleagues or family members won’t be disturbed by your work calls or music. In addition, closed-back headphones often offer a more detailed and pronounced bass response, which is great for music enthusiasts.

The sealed design of the ear cups helps to contain the bass frequencies, resulting in a richer and more immersive listening experience. Closed-back headsets also tend to have a wider frequency response range, which means that they can reproduce a greater range of frequencies and nuances in sound, making them ideal for music production or audio editing work.

Overall, if you’re looking for a headset that offers excellent noise isolation, focused sound, and detailed bass response, a closed-back headset may be the right choice for you.

Sound Quality Comparison

When it comes to sound quality, you need to pay attention to three key factors: frequency response, impedance, and sensitivity.

The frequency response refers to the range of sound frequencies that the headset can accurately reproduce, with a wider range providing a more immersive listening experience.

The impedance is the amount of electrical resistance the headset presents to the audio source, affecting how loud and clear the sound is.

And finally, the sensitivity measures how efficiently the headset converts electrical signals into sound, affecting the overall volume and clarity of the audio.

By understanding these factors, you can choose a headset that delivers the sound quality you need for work or entertainment.

Frequency Response

The bass on closed-back headsets often feels more pronounced, but the frequency response of open-back headsets allows for a more balanced soundstage. The frequency response refers to the range of frequencies that a headset can produce, and it can greatly impact the listening experience. Open-back headsets typically have a wider frequency response range, allowing for more detail and nuance in the sound.

To better understand the frequency response differences between open-back and closed-back headsets, take a look at the table below. It compares the frequency response ranges of two popular work from home headsets: the Sennheiser HD 660 S (open-back) and the Sony WH-1000XM4 (closed-back). As you can see, the Sennheiser headset has a much wider frequency range, allowing for a more nuanced and detailed sound. However, the Sony headset has a more pronounced bass response, which some listeners may prefer for certain types of music.

Sennheiser HD 660 S (open-back)Sony WH-1000XM4 (closed-back)
Frequency Range10Hz – 41kHz4Hz – 40kHz
Impedance150 ohms47 ohms
Sensitivity104dB SPL/1V RMS104.5dB/mW (1kHz)

Overall, when it comes to frequency response, open-back headsets tend to offer a more balanced and nuanced soundstage. However, closed-back headsets may be preferred by some listeners who prefer a more pronounced bass response. It ultimately depends on personal preference and the type of music or audio being listened to.

Impedance

Impedance, like the electrical resistance in a water pipe, can affect the flow of sound in a headset. In simple terms, impedance is the measure of how much resistance a headset provides to the flow of electrical signals. The higher the impedance, the more difficult it is for the electrical signal to pass through the headset. This can result in a lower volume output and reduced sound quality, particularly in low-frequency sounds.

When it comes to work from home headsets, impedance is an important consideration. Closed-back headsets typically have higher impedance levels than open-back headsets because they’re designed to block out external noise and provide better isolation. However, this higher impedance can also result in a reduced soundstage, which can affect the overall quality of the audio experience.

On the other hand, open-back headsets typically have lower impedance levels, which can result in a wider soundstage and better overall sound quality. Ultimately, the choice between open-back and closed-back headsets will depend on your personal preferences and the type of audio you’ll be using them for.

Sensitivity

Sensitivity is another factor to consider when choosing a headset for your work from home setup. It’s a measure of how efficiently the headphones can convert electrical signals into sound. Headphones with higher sensitivity ratings require less power to produce the same volume as headphones with lower sensitivity ratings.

Here are some things to keep in mind when choosing a headset based on sensitivity:

  1. Sensitivity is measured in decibels (dB) per milliwatt (mW) and generally ranges from 85 dB/mW to 120 dB/mW. The higher the sensitivity rating, the louder the headphones will sound at the same volume level.

  2. High-sensitivity headphones can be driven by portable devices like smartphones or laptops without the need for an external amplifier. However, they may also be more prone to distortion at high volumes.

  3. Low-sensitivity headphones require more power to deliver the same volume, which means they may require an external amplifier to perform optimally. However, they may also provide better sound quality at lower volumes and be less prone to distortion.

  4. Sensitivity ratings do not necessarily correlate with sound quality. Other factors like frequency response, distortion, and soundstage should also be considered when choosing a headset for your work from home setup.

When choosing a headset based on sensitivity, it’s important to consider your listening habits and the devices you will be using them with. High-sensitivity headphones may be ideal for on-the-go listening with portable devices, while low-sensitivity headphones may be better suited for home listening with dedicated audio equipment. However, sensitivity is just one piece of the puzzle when it comes to finding the perfect headset for your work from home setup.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Open-Back and Closed-Back Headsets

When choosing between open-back and closed-back headsets, there are several factors to consider. Firstly, your environment plays a significant role in determining which headset is best suited for you. If you work in a noisy environment, a closed-back headset may be the better choice as it offers better noise isolation.

Secondly, personal preference is important as both types of headsets have their own unique sound signature. Lastly, your budget will also play a role in your decision-making process as open-back headsets tend to be more expensive due to their superior soundstage.

Environment

In your home office, you’ll notice a significant difference in sound quality between open-back and closed-back headsets based on the environment you’re in.

If you’re in a quiet room and don’t want to disturb others, a closed-back headset will be your best option. The closed-back design blocks out external noise and prevents sound leakage, ensuring that your audio experience is not interrupted by any distractions.

On the other hand, if you’re in a noisy environment and need to stay aware of your surroundings, an open-back headset would be the way to go. With its unique design, an open-back headset allows air and sound to flow freely through the ear cups, creating a more natural and spacious sound.

This is perfect if you’re looking for a headset that offers better soundstage and a more immersive audio experience. However, keep in mind that this type of headset may not be suitable for all environments and may not be the best choice if you need to keep your audio private.

Personal Preference

Your personal preference plays a key role in choosing the right headset for you, as it determines the level of comfort and sound quality that you require for your audio experience.

When it comes to open-back and closed-back headsets, your preference will depend on what you prioritize. If you value isolation and privacy, then a closed-back headset is the way to go. Closed-back headsets provide excellent noise isolation, which means that you can work in peace without being disturbed by external noises. They are perfect for those who work in noisy environments or have people around them who make a lot of noise.

On the other hand, if you value a wider soundstage and more natural sound, then an open-back headset is the better choice. Open-back headsets allow sound to pass through the ear cups, resulting in a more natural sound that is similar to listening to speakers in a room. They also offer a wider soundstage, which means that you can hear sounds from different directions and distances. This is particularly useful for those who work with music or audio production, as it provides a more accurate representation of the sound.

Ultimately, your personal preference will determine which headset is right for you, so be sure to consider your needs and priorities before making a decision.

Budget

Now that you’ve considered your personal preference when it comes to open-back and closed-back headsets, it’s time to think about your budget. This is an important factor to consider as it can greatly affect the overall quality of the headset you choose.

Closed-back headphones tend to be more affordable than open-back headphones. This is because the closed-back design makes them easier to manufacture, which results in a lower cost. However, this doesn’t mean that closed-back headphones are of lower quality.

There are many great closed-back headphones available that offer excellent sound quality and durability. On the other hand, open-back headphones can be more expensive due to the more complex design and materials used. If you have a larger budget, an open-back headset may be worth considering as they often offer a wider soundstage and more natural sound reproduction.

However, if you’re on a tighter budget, a closed-back headset may be a more practical choice.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do open-back and closed-back headsets affect the quality of voice calls?

Open-back and closed-back headsets can have a significant impact on the quality of voice calls. Open-back headsets typically have a more natural and spacious sound, which can make voices sound more natural and clear. However, they also allow more external noise to enter the headset, which can be distracting during calls.

Closed-back headsets, on the other hand, offer better noise isolation, making them ideal for use in noisy environments. They also tend to have a more focused and intimate sound, which can make voices sound more present and detailed.

Ultimately, the choice between open-back and closed-back headsets for voice calls will depend on your specific needs and preferences, as both types have their own unique advantages and disadvantages.

Can open-back headsets be used in noisy environments like cafes or airports?

You may be wondering if open-back headsets can be used in noisy environments like cafes or airports. The answer is that while open-back headphones offer a more natural soundstage and better audio quality, they also allow outside noise to filter in.

This means that in loud environments, the outside noise can interfere with your audio experience. Closed-back headphones, on the other hand, offer better noise isolation and are better suited for use in loud environments.

So while open-back headphones may be a great choice for use at home or in a quiet office, they may not be the best choice for noisy environments.

Do closed-back headsets cause sweating or discomfort during extended use?

Closed-back headsets can cause sweating or discomfort during extended use due to the lack of ventilation and isolation of the ear cups. This can result in the accumulation of heat and moisture around the ears, leading to discomfort and even irritation. However, some closed-back headsets come with breathable materials and cooling pads that help alleviate this issue.

It’s important to consider the quality of materials, padding, and ventilation when choosing a closed-back headset for extended use. Additionally, taking breaks and adjusting the fit of the headset can also help reduce discomfort.

Are there any specific types of music or audio that sound better on open-back or closed-back headsets?

When it comes to choosing between open-back and closed-back headphones for listening to music or audio, there are some differences you should keep in mind. Generally speaking, open-back headphones tend to offer a wider soundstage and more natural sound due to their design, which allows air to pass through and create a more spacious listening experience.

On the other hand, closed-back headphones are better at isolating sound and preventing sound leakage, making them a good choice for environments where you don’t want to disturb others or be disturbed yourself.

As for specific types of music or audio, it really depends on personal preference and the nuances of each individual recording. However, some people find that open-back headphones are better for classical music or jazz, while closed-back headphones are better for electronic or bass-heavy music.

Ultimately, the best choice for you will depend on your listening habits and needs.

How do the prices of open-back and closed-back headsets compare?

When it comes to comparing the prices of open-back and closed-back headsets, there are a few factors to consider. Generally, open-back headsets tend to be more expensive due to their design and the materials used. They often have larger drivers and a more intricate design to allow for the open-back soundstage.

Closed-back headsets, on the other hand, are often more affordable as they can be made with simpler materials and design. However, it’s important to note that there are high-end closed-back headsets that can be just as expensive as open-back ones.

Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference and budget when deciding between the two types of headsets.

Conclusion

In conclusion, when it comes to selecting the right headset for remote work, there are many factors to consider. Open-back and closed-back headsets both have their advantages and disadvantages, and the decision ultimately comes down to personal preference and work requirements.

If you prioritize soundstage and prefer a more natural, spacious sound, then an open-back headset may be the right choice for you. On the other hand, if you require isolation and need to work in a noisy environment, a closed-back headset may be the way to go.

Ultimately, it’s important to consider sound quality, comfort, and work requirements when selecting a headset for remote work. By taking the time to understand the differences between open-back and closed-back headsets, you can make an informed decision that will enhance your productivity and comfort while working from home.

More Post Related To

Work From Home Headset
William A. Lucas

What Are The Benefits Of Wireless Work From Home Headsets?

If you’re working from home, investing in a wireless headset can make all the difference in your daily routine. Not only do they give you greater mobility around your workspace, but they also provide excellent sound quality, improved productivity, and comfort that can last

Read More »
Work From Home Headset
William A. Lucas

What Are The Best Work From Home Headsets For Video Conferencing?

If you’re working from home and attending video conferences regularly, you know how important it is to have a reliable headset that delivers crystal-clear audio and eliminates background noise. Whether you’re presenting your ideas to colleagues, discussing projects with clients, or attending virtual meetings,

Read More »
Work From Home Headset
William A. Lucas

Where To Find The Best Work From Home Headset Deals?

If you’re working from home, you know the importance of having a good headset. It’s not only essential for communication with your colleagues or clients but also helps you focus and minimize background noise. However, finding the best work from home headset deals can

Read More »

Continue Reading

Gaming Headset
William A. Lucas

Who Should Invest In A Gaming Headset?

If you’re an avid gamer, you know that having the right equipment is essential to your gaming experience. One piece of equipment that you may be considering is a gaming headset. While not every gamer may need a headset, there are certain types of

Read More »
Gaming Headset
William A. Lucas

Who Should Consider Noise-Canceling Gaming Headsets?

If you’re a gamer, you know how important it is to have the right equipment. From keyboards to mice to monitors, every piece of gear can make a difference in your gaming experience. But have you considered investing in a noise-canceling gaming headset? These

Read More »
Gaming Headset
William A. Lucas

Who Benefits The Most From Using A Gaming Headset?

Do you want to elevate your gaming experience to the next level? Then a gaming headset might just be the perfect solution for you. Not only does it provide you with high-quality sound, but it also offers unparalleled comfort and design. But, who benefits

Read More »
Gaming Headset
William A. Lucas

What To Expect From High-End Gaming Headsets?

If you’re a gamer, you know that having the right gear is crucial for a truly immersive gaming experience. And when it comes to sound, nothing beats a high-end gaming headset. But what exactly should you expect from these top-of-the-line devices? First and foremost,

Read More »
Gaming Headset
William A. Lucas

What To Consider When Choosing A Gaming Headset?

When it comes to gaming, a good headset can make all the difference. Whether you’re playing a first-person shooter or a multiplayer online battle arena game, the right headset can provide you with the edge you need to win. But with so many options

Read More »
Gaming Headset
William A. Lucas

How To Troubleshoot Common Issues With Your Gaming Headset?

If you’re an avid gamer, there’s nothing more frustrating than having your headset malfunction mid-game. Whether you’re experiencing connectivity issues, poor sound quality, or general wear and tear, troubleshooting common issues with your gaming headset can be a daunting task. However, with a little

Read More »
Scroll to Top